[ READ EPUB ] ☪ Power and Powerlessness: Quiescence and Rebellion in an Appalachian Valley ♊ MOBI eBook or Kindle ePUB free

I was expecting this book to be a good, informative analysis of working class Appalachia, but it completely exceeded my expectations in every way To say I was blown away by it would likely be a bit of an understatement.If you can make it past the theory and jargon heavy first chapter which ends up being tremendously useful later on you will be rewarded with not only a history of Central Appalachian working class struggles, or their often apparent absence, but also with a new and unique way o I was expecting this book to be a good, informative analysis of working class Appalachia, but it completely exceeded my expectations in every way To say I was blown away by it would likely be a bit of an understatement.If you can make it past the theory and jargon heavy first chapter which ends up being tremendously useful later on you will be rewarded with not only a history of Central Appalachian working class struggles, or their often apparent absence, but also with a new and unique way of looking at power relations and the theory behind them The primary question the book seeks to explore is why, in the face of obvious abuse, oppression, and exploitation of coal miner at the hands of the coal companies, their local governments, and the unions that allegedly represent their interests, do the coal miners and other residents in the Clear Fork Valley NOT rebel Not just that, but often they seem to be complicit in the very processes that keep them in a position of powerlessness and poverty This opens up Gaventa s ideas of a new way of analyzing power relations, called a third dimensional approach, that suggests the miners and their neighbors aren t idly accepting their fate and gives some hope that, if they are ever able to strike at the roots of the power structure in their environment, there can be hope for meaningful change.It s, at times, a dark, frustrating, and deeply upsettng book It also offers, however, a beacon of hope for the struggles the people of Central Appalachia, and indeed the millions of working class people around the world who find themselves in strikingly similar situations.If you are at all interested in the post Foucalt theory of power relations, working class struggles, or Appalachian history, you NEED to read this book Borrow mine if you must, but read it, and read it now I read this in a Political Sociology graduate seminar It is a great piece on the dynamics of power in society It presents an excellent quality analysis and development of social theory concepts, and is also a well written historical account of a truly shocking period in US history This one has really stuck with me through the years. This is a wonderful book that explains why people in an Appalachian coal mining region were unable to break free of the power exerted over them by the mining company and the mining unions This book is one of the best discussions of political and social power I have ever read those who have read work on the third face of power will find this book extremely interesting and useful I will writeabout this when I have time, but I can say this this is one of the most interesting books I rea This is a wonderful book that explains why people in an Appalachian coal mining region were unable to break free of the power exerted over them by the mining company and the mining unions This book is one of the best discussions of political and social power I have ever read those who have read work on the third face of power will find this book extremely interesting and useful I will writeabout this when I have time, but I can say this this is one of the most interesting books I read during my graduate school career This book changed my whole world view when it came to politics It had a profound effect on me, giving me a better idea of who I was, where I came from and what created the situation of the community around me In addition to giving me tools to understand what had happened and was happening, it gave me the first suggestions of the kind of things needed to do to change things Most importantly, that understanding also gave me something very important hope. [ READ EPUB ] ⚔ Power and Powerlessness: Quiescence and Rebellion in an Appalachian Valley ♕ Explains to outsiders the conflicts between the financial interests of the coal and land companies, and the moral rights of the vulnerable mountaineers My first solid understandings of unions and where they re effectiveand necessary. lacks any real discussion of race or even why race is not important The second face of power is placing barriers to participation, and the third face of power is molding ideology to prevent challenges from even being conceived Interesting history of coal unionism including John L Lewis and Jock Yablonski Ralph Nader pops up, as does Paulo Freire. i like it Gaventa performs well at providing an academic analysis of the development and maintenance of power relationships in the Appalachian region With equal skill, he provides a qualitative history of the relevant aspects of the region, such as they way in which capital based in London and New York inserted proxies in to the local political and cultural institutions to maintain their control of the region s resources The nature of capital s control over property is nothing new Gaventa is most poig Gaventa performs well at providing an academic analysis of the development and maintenance of power relationships in the Appalachian region With equal skill, he provides a qualitative history of the relevant aspects of the region, such as they way in which capital based in London and New York inserted proxies in to the local political and cultural institutions to maintain their control of the region s resources The nature of capital s control over property is nothing new Gaventa is most poignant when he outlines the way in which cultural stereotypes of hill people have been, and remain, useful in deflecting attention from injustice in the region That said, for those not interested in social research methodology congratulations, you probably can form meaningful relationships the later chapters will beenjoyable and don t necessarily require the methodological buildup of the early chapters